Peppermint Bark Butterfinger Candy Bars: Ultimate Holiday Treat

There’s something magical about the combination of chocolate and peppermint during the holiday season. Add Butterfingers to the mix, and you’ve created an irresistible treat that brings together the best of both worlds – the classic peppermint bark we all adore and the crunchy, peanut buttery goodness of Butterfinger candy bars. These Peppermint Bark Butterfinger Candy Bars are destined to become the star of your holiday dessert table or gift-giving tradition.

This indulgent creation layers creamy white chocolate infused with refreshing peppermint, adorned with festive pink swirls, and topped with full-size Butterfinger bars for a satisfying crunch that takes ordinary peppermint bark to extraordinary heights. The contrast between the smooth peppermint-infused white chocolate and the crackling texture of Butterfingers creates a multi-dimensional treat that delights with every bite.

Whether you’re looking for a show-stopping dessert for your holiday gathering, a thoughtful homemade gift, or simply a special treat to enjoy with your family, these Peppermint Bark Butterfinger Candy Bars deliver on both impressive presentation and incredible flavor. Let’s dive into this festive creation that combines nostalgic holiday flavors with a creative twist!

Why You’ll Love These Peppermint Bark Butterfinger Candy Bars

If you’re wondering whether these candy bars are worth the effort, let me assure you that they absolutely are! This recipe transforms ordinary ingredients into something extraordinary with minimal effort, and the results will have everyone asking for the recipe. Here’s why these Peppermint Bark Butterfinger Candy Bars deserve a place in your holiday baking lineup:

First, the visual impact is undeniable. The marbled pink and white peppermint bark base, topped with neat rows of Butterfinger bars and finished with an elegant white chocolate drizzle, creates a striking presentation that looks professional despite being surprisingly simple to execute. These candy bars will stand out on any holiday dessert table or gift tray.

The flavor combination is truly special – the cool, refreshing peppermint pairs unexpectedly well with the peanut buttery crunch of Butterfingers. While peppermint bark is a holiday classic, the addition of Butterfingers elevates it to a whole new level of deliciousness. The hint of salt balances the sweetness perfectly, creating a more sophisticated flavor profile than traditional candy bars.

What’s more, these bars offer a wonderful textural experience. The smooth, creamy peppermint bark provides a satisfying foundation that contrasts beautifully with the distinctive crispy, flaky texture of Butterfinger bars. Each bite delivers multiple textures and flavors that make this treat truly memorable.

Perhaps best of all, this recipe requires no baking! It’s primarily a matter of melting, assembling, and chilling, making it accessible even for those who don’t consider themselves confident bakers. The straightforward process yields impressive results that belie the minimal effort involved.

Finally, these Peppermint Bark Butterfinger Candy Bars make perfect gifts. Wrapped in cellophane with a festive ribbon, they’re an impressive homemade treat that friends and family will genuinely appreciate receiving. Who wouldn’t prefer these unique candy bars over another fruitcake?

Ingredients for Perfect Peppermint Bark Butterfinger Candy Bars

Creating these festive treats starts with gathering quality ingredients. Let’s break down each component and why it matters for the perfect Peppermint Bark Butterfinger Candy Bars:

The Foundations

• 12 full-size Butterfinger candy bars (about 5 1/4 oz each): These provide the star power of this recipe. The distinctive honeycomb toffee interior of Butterfingers creates a crispy, peanut buttery layer that contrasts beautifully with the smooth peppermint bark. Full-size bars ensure substantial pieces in every bite.
• 16 oz (1 lb) high-quality white chocolate: Don’t skimp here! Quality white chocolate makes a noticeable difference in both taste and texture. Look for products containing cocoa butter rather than vegetable oils for the smoothest melt and richest flavor. Brands like Ghirardelli, Lindt, or Baker’s yield superior results.

Flavor Enhancers

• 1 tsp peppermint extract: The pure version delivers a clean, natural peppermint flavor without the chemical aftertaste of imitation extracts. A little goes a long way, so measure carefully – too much can overpower the other flavors and create a medicinal taste.
• 1/2 tsp vanilla extract: This often-overlooked ingredient adds depth and warmth to the white chocolate, creating a more complex flavor profile that complements the peppermint beautifully.
• 1/4 tsp salt: This small but crucial ingredient balances the sweetness and enhances the flavors of both the white chocolate and the Butterfingers. Don’t skip it!

Visual Elements

• 3-4 drops red food coloring: Gel food coloring provides the vibrant pink swirl without diluting the chocolate. The pink marbling isn’t just for looks – it visually signals the peppermint flavor and creates a festive appearance perfect for holiday celebrations.
• Optional: crushed candy canes or peppermint bits: These add extra peppermint punch and festive appearance. They’re optional but contribute additional texture and visual appeal if you choose to include them.

Each ingredient plays a purposeful role in creating these spectacular candy bars. The balance of flavors and textures elevates this treat from a simple combination of components to a truly special dessert worthy of your holiday traditions.

Essential Equipment for Making Peppermint Bark Butterfinger Candy Bars

While this recipe doesn’t require specialized baking equipment, having the right tools will make the process smoother and yield the best results. Here’s what you’ll need to create perfect Peppermint Bark Butterfinger Candy Bars:

Basic Equipment

• 9×13-inch baking pan: This provides just the right depth and surface area for the bark layer and Butterfinger arrangement. A metal pan conducts cold better than glass for quicker setting, but either works well.
• Parchment paper: Essential for easy removal and clean cutting. The overhang serves as handles to lift the entire slab out intact, so don’t skip this step!
• Double boiler or heatproof bowl: For gently melting white chocolate without scorching it. White chocolate is particularly sensitive to overheating, so indirect heat is crucial for smooth results.
• Silicone spatula: Ideal for folding and stirring chocolate without introducing air bubbles, plus it scrapes the bowl clean, ensuring you don’t waste any of that precious melted chocolate.

Helpful Tools

• Kitchen scale: For precisely dividing the melted chocolate between the white and pink portions. While not strictly necessary, it helps ensure consistent results.
• Offset spatula: Creates the smoothest, most even layer of bark. Its angled design makes spreading much easier than using a regular knife or spatula.
• Skewer or butter knife: For creating those beautiful marble swirls between the white and pink chocolate without overmixing.
• Sharp chef’s knife: Essential for clean cuts through the finished bars. Warming the blade as suggested in the instructions makes a significant difference in cutting quality.

Optional But Useful

• Candy thermometer: If you’re concerned about tempering the white chocolate properly, this helps monitor the temperature to prevent blooming (those white streaks that can appear when chocolate sets improperly).
• Small piping bag: For creating more precise drizzles with the final white chocolate layer. A zip-top bag with a tiny corner snipped off works as a substitute.
• Ruler: If you’re aiming for perfectly uniform bars, marking cutting lines with a ruler before slicing helps achieve professional-looking results.

Most home cooks will already have these basic tools, making this an accessible recipe regardless of your kitchen equipment collection. The simplicity of required tools is part of what makes these Peppermint Bark Butterfinger Candy Bars so approachable despite their impressive appearance.

Step-by-Step Process for Making Peppermint Bark Butterfinger Candy Bars

Creating these festive treats is surprisingly straightforward, but attention to detail makes the difference between good and exceptional results. Follow these detailed steps for candy bar perfection:

Preparation Phase

1. Set up your workspace: Before starting, ensure you have all ingredients measured and equipment ready. Working with chocolate requires timely execution, so preparation is key.
2. Prepare the pan: Line your 9×13-inch baking pan with parchment paper, leaving overhang on two opposing sides. Smooth the parchment against the bottom and sides of the pan, creating sharp corners for the neatest presentation.
3. Prepare Butterfingers: Keep the candy bars in their wrappers until needed to prevent them from warming or breaking. If your kitchen is warm, consider chilling them briefly for easier handling.

Creating the Peppermint Bark Base

1. Melt the base chocolate: Set up your double boiler with 1-2 inches of water in the bottom pot, ensuring the water doesn’t touch the upper bowl. Bring to a gentle simmer. Place 12 oz of white chocolate in the top bowl and stir occasionally with a silicone spatula until completely smooth. Maintain low heat – white chocolate scorches easily!
2. Add flavor: Remove from heat and immediately stir in the peppermint extract, vanilla extract, and salt. The warmth of the chocolate will help distribute the flavors evenly. Stir gently but thoroughly to incorporate.
3. Create two-tone mixture: Divide the melted chocolate equally between two bowls (about 6 oz each). Add the red food coloring to one portion, starting with just 2-3 drops and adding more if needed until you achieve a pretty pink color. Stir thoroughly to eliminate any streaks of color.
4. Form the bark layer: Pour the plain white chocolate evenly into the prepared pan, using an offset spatula to spread it into a smooth, even layer. Immediately drizzle the pink chocolate across the top in parallel lines or a zigzag pattern.
5. Create marble effect: While both chocolates are still fluid, use a skewer or butter knife to gently swirl them together. Draw the tool through both colors in a figure-eight or S-pattern, being careful not to overmix. You want distinct swirls of pink and white, not a uniform pink mixture.

Adding the Butterfinger Layer

1. Position Butterfingers: Working quickly while the chocolate is still soft, arrange the Butterfinger bars in neat rows on top of the swirled chocolate. Press them down gently so they adhere to the base but don’t sink completely into the chocolate.
2. Add optional garnish: If using crushed candy canes or peppermint bits, sprinkle them in the spaces between the Butterfinger bars or along the edges of the pan for a festive touch.
3. Create the drizzle: Melt the remaining 4 oz of white chocolate using the same double-boiler method. Once smooth, drizzle it in a crisscross pattern over the arranged Butterfinger bars. This not only looks attractive but helps secure everything together.

Setting and Serving

1. Chill properly: Refrigerate the entire pan for at least 1 hour until completely firm. The chocolate should feel solid to the touch with no soft spots. Alternatively, freeze for 30 minutes if you’re short on time.
2. Remove from pan: Once set, use the parchment paper overhang to gently lift the entire slab out of the pan. Place it on a cutting board.
3. Cut into portions: Warm a sharp knife under hot water, wipe dry, and slice the slab into bars or squares. Rewarm and wipe the knife between cuts for the cleanest edges. You can cut along the natural divisions created by the Butterfinger bars or create smaller pieces as desired.
4. Store properly: Place finished bars in a single layer in an airtight container, separating layers with parchment paper if stacking. Store at room temperature (if your kitchen isn’t too warm) or in the refrigerator for up to two weeks.

Following this detailed process ensures professional-looking Peppermint Bark Butterfinger Candy Bars that taste as impressive as they look. The combination of careful chocolate handling and proper setting creates that perfect snap of quality bark complemented by the distinctive Butterfinger crunch.

Creative Variations for Peppermint Bark Butterfinger Candy Bars

While the classic version of these Peppermint Bark Butterfinger Candy Bars is spectacular on its own, experimenting with variations can keep this recipe fresh and exciting year after year. Here are some creative twists to consider:

Alternative Chocolate Combinations

• Dark Chocolate Base: Replace half of the white chocolate in the base with high-quality dark chocolate for a striking color contrast and more complex flavor profile. The bitterness of dark chocolate pairs beautifully with both peppermint and the sweetness of Butterfingers.
• Milk Chocolate Drizzle: Substitute milk chocolate for the white chocolate drizzle on top for a different visual appearance and complementary flavor that enhances the peanut butter notes in the Butterfingers.
• Layered Approach: Create a tri-colored bark by first laying down a thin dark chocolate layer, allowing it to partially set, then topping with the white and pink peppermint bark before adding the Butterfingers.

Flavor Twists

• Orange-Mint Fusion: Add 1/4 teaspoon of orange extract alongside the peppermint for a chocolate-orange-mint combination reminiscent of those chocolate oranges popular during the holidays.
• Almond Joy Inspiration: Mix 1/2 cup toasted coconut flakes into the melted white chocolate and replace the peppermint extract with 1/4 teaspoon coconut extract for a completely different flavor profile.
• Mocha Peppermint: Dissolve 1 tablespoon espresso powder in 1 teaspoon hot water, then add to the white chocolate alongside the peppermint extract for a coffee-infused variation.

Candy Bar Alternatives

• Mixed Candy Bar Medley: Use a variety of candy bars instead of just Butterfingers. Try alternating rows of Butterfingers, Snickers, and Kit Kats for a candy lover’s dream combination.
• Bite-Sized Version: Instead of full-size Butterfingers, use the mini or fun-size versions arranged in a mosaic pattern for smaller portions and more varied cutting options.
• Crumbled Integration: Roughly chop or crush 6 of the Butterfinger bars and mix them directly into the white chocolate base, then arrange the remaining 6 bars on top for maximum Butterfinger presence throughout each bite.

Presentation Variations

• Cookie Base: Press the peppermint bark mixture onto a layer of shortbread cookie dough that’s been partially baked, creating a cookie-bark hybrid with added texture and flavor.
• Individual Portions: Rather than making one large slab, use a muffin tin lined with paper cups to create individual bark cups. Place a piece of Butterfinger in each cup after pouring in the swirled chocolate.
• Bark Bites: Cut the finished bark into small, bite-sized pieces and dip half of each piece in dark chocolate for an elegant two-tone effect perfect for gift boxes.

These variations maintain the spirit of the original Peppermint Bark Butterfinger Candy Bars while offering new taste experiences and presentation options. Don’t be afraid to experiment and create your own unique version that might become your family’s new favorite holiday tradition!

Serving and Gift-Giving Ideas for Peppermint Bark Butterfinger Candy Bars

These spectacular Peppermint Bark Butterfinger Candy Bars deserve to be showcased, whether you’re serving them at a gathering or giving them as gifts. Here are creative ways to present and share these festive treats:

Holiday Party Presentation

• Dessert Board Centerpiece: Create a holiday dessert board with your Peppermint Bark Butterfinger Candy Bars as the star. Surround them with complementary treats like chocolate-dipped pretzels, fresh berries, and mint chocolate cookies for an impressive spread.
• Tiered Display: Arrange the bars on a tiered cake stand, interspersed with sprigs of fresh mint and tiny ornaments for a festive holiday centerpiece that doubles as dessert.
• Hot Chocolate Pairing Station: Set up a hot chocolate bar with these candy bars on the side. Guests can either enjoy them separately or use the bars as stirrers that melt partially into the hot chocolate for a peppermint mocha experience.
• Dessert Wine Pairing: Serve smaller pieces alongside glasses of ruby port or late-harvest Zinfandel. The sweetness of the wine complements the peppermint and chocolate beautifully for an adult dessert experience.

Gifting Presentations

• Holiday Cookie Boxes: Include these bars as the premium item in holiday cookie boxes. Their impressive appearance will elevate the entire gift, and their sturdy nature means they’ll transport well.
• Mason Jar Gifts: Layer bite-sized pieces in a mason jar, alternating with crushed candy canes for a striking visual effect. Add a ribbon and gift tag for a charming, homemade gift.
• Custom Gift Bags: Place bars in clear cellophane bags tied with red and white baker’s twine or ribbon. Add a custom tag with the recipe name and a note about how to store them.
• Teacher or Neighbor Gifts: Package a few bars in a festive tin lined with holiday tissue paper. These make perfect thank-you gifts for teachers, mail carriers, or neighbors during the holiday season.

Long-Term Storage Tips

• Refrigeration: While these bars can be stored at room temperature for a few days, refrigeration extends their shelf life to about two weeks. Just be sure to store them in an airtight container.
• Freezing Option: These bars freeze beautifully for up to three months. Layer them between sheets of parchment in an airtight container, then thaw in the refrigerator before serving.
• Shipping Considerations: If shipping these as gifts, refrigerate them thoroughly first, then pack with ice packs or frozen gel packs. Choose expedited shipping during warmer weather to ensure they arrive in perfect condition.

The versatility of these Peppermint Bark Butterfinger Candy Bars makes them ideal for nearly any holiday occasion. Their impressive appearance belies how simple they are to make, and their unique flavor combination guarantees they’ll be remembered long after the holiday season ends.

Common Questions About Peppermint Bark Butterfinger Candy Bars

When making these festive treats, you might encounter some questions along the way. Here are answers to the most common queries about creating perfect Peppermint Bark Butterfinger Candy Bars:

Can I use chocolate chips instead of bar chocolate?

While chocolate chips can work in a pinch, they contain stabilizers that can affect melting quality. For the smoothest results, opt for high-quality white chocolate bars or wafers specifically designed for melting. If you must use chips, look for premium brands with higher cocoa butter content.

My white chocolate seized when I added the extracts. What happened?

This common issue occurs when even a tiny droplet of water contacts the melted chocolate or when extracts are added to overheated chocolate. To prevent seizing: 1) Make sure your bowls and utensils are completely dry, 2) Remove the chocolate from heat before adding extracts, 3) Consider warming the extracts slightly before adding them, and 4) Add extracts gradually while stirring constantly.

Can I make these without peppermint extract?

Absolutely! While the peppermint flavor creates the classic “bark” experience, you can substitute other extracts like almond, orange, or coconut for different flavor profiles. Adjust quantities accordingly, as some extracts are stronger than others.

My Butterfingers are sinking into the chocolate. How can I prevent this?

If your Butterfingers are sinking, the chocolate layer is likely too warm. Let the swirled chocolate set for 2-3 minutes until it’s just beginning to set at the edges before positioning the candy bars. Alternatively, you can let the chocolate set completely, then “glue” the Butterfingers on top with a fresh layer of melted chocolate.

How can I get perfectly clean cuts?

For professional-looking cuts: 1) Chill the bark thoroughly, 2) Use a large, sharp chef’s knife, 3) Run the blade under hot water and wipe dry before each cut, 4) Apply firm, even pressure straight down rather than sawing, and 5) Consider using a ruler as a guide for straight lines.

Can I use other candy bars instead of Butterfingers?

Definitely! This recipe works wonderfully with other candy bars like Snickers, Twix, Kit Kat, or Reese’s Cups. Choose bars with textures and flavors that complement the peppermint bark base. You may need to adjust quantities based on the size of your substitute candy bars.

My bark doesn’t have that nice snap. It’s too soft. What went wrong?

Soft bark typically indicates that the chocolate wasn’t properly tempered or contained too many additives. Using high-quality white chocolate with real cocoa butter and ensuring proper cooling will help achieve that satisfying snap. Additionally, storing the bars in the refrigerator can improve the texture.

How far in advance can I make these for holiday gifts?

These bars keep well for up to two weeks when stored properly in an airtight container in the refrigerator. For optimal freshness when giving as gifts, aim to make them no more than a week before gifting. They can also be frozen for up to three months and thawed before packaging.

My white chocolate has white streaks after setting. What caused this?

Those white streaks, known as “bloom,” occur when chocolate isn’t tempered properly or experiences temperature fluctuations during setting. While it doesn’t affect taste, to prevent bloom in future batches: 1) Melt chocolate slowly and gently, 2) Avoid rapid temperature changes, and 3) Consider using the seeding method of tempering for more stable results.

Can this recipe be doubled for larger batches?

Yes, this recipe scales well. For a double batch, use a half-sheet pan (approximately 18×13 inches) instead of the 9×13-inch pan. All of the process steps remain the same, though you may need slightly longer setting time for the larger volume.

These answers should help troubleshoot any issues and ensure your Peppermint Bark Butterfinger Candy Bars turn out perfectly every time. Remember that chocolate work improves with practice, so don’t be discouraged if your first batch isn’t perfect – they’ll still be delicious!

Nutritional Information and Serving Suggestions

While these Peppermint Bark Butterfinger Candy Bars are definitely an indulgent treat, understanding their nutritional profile can help you enjoy them mindfully during the holiday season. Here’s what you should know about these festive candy bars:

Nutritional Considerations

These candy bars are a special holiday indulgence rather than an everyday snack. Each serving (approximately a 2-inch square piece) contains:

• Calories: Approximately 250-300 calories
• Fat: 15-18g (with 9-10g being saturated fat from the white chocolate)
• Carbohydrates: 30-35g, with about 28g being sugar
• Protein: 3g
• Sodium: 150mg

The nutritional profile varies based on the exact size of your portions and the specific brands of chocolate and candy bars used. When enjoying these as part of your holiday celebrations, consider the following mindful approaches:

Balanced Serving Suggestions

• Portion Control: Cut smaller pieces (approximately 1×1 inch) for a taste of indulgence without overindulging. These are rich treats where a little goes a long way.
• Pairing Options: Serve with fresh fruits like strawberries or raspberries to balance the sweetness and add nutritional value to your dessert plate.
• Beverage Complements: Pair with unsweetened hot tea, coffee, or even sparkling water with a twist of citrus to offset the sweetness rather than adding more sugar with sweet beverages.
• Meal Timing: Enjoy these treats after a balanced meal containing protein and fiber to minimize blood sugar spikes and make the indulgence more satisfying.

Storage for Freshness

Proper storage not only maintains quality but also helps with portion control:

• Individual Wrapping: Consider wrapping pieces individually in wax paper or parchment paper before storing them in an airtight container. This extra step creates a small mindfulness moment before enjoying a piece.
• Freezer Storage: Freezing portioned pieces extends shelf life and creates a built-in delay factor when you want one—they take a few minutes to thaw to the ideal texture.
• Visual Cues: Store in opaque containers rather than clear ones to reduce visual temptation when opening the refrigerator.

Remember that holiday traditions and special treats are an important part of celebration. These Peppermint Bark Butterfinger Candy Bars are meant to be enjoyed mindfully as part of your festive season, bringing joy through their delicious flavor and the experience of sharing them with loved ones.

More Related Recipes You Might Enjoy

If you love these Peppermint Bark Butterfinger Candy Bars, here are some other festive holiday treats from our collection that feature similar flavors, techniques, or holiday appeal:

Christmas Peanut Butter Balls

These no-bake treats share the peanut butter flavor profile of Butterfingers and the easy preparation method of our candy bars. Featuring a smooth peanut butter center coated in chocolate and festive sprinkles, they make the perfect companion to your holiday dessert spread or gift basket.

Christmas Maraschino Cherry Shortbread

Another festive red and white treat, these buttery shortbread cookies studded with bright maraschino cherries offer a different texture but similar visual appeal to our peppermint bark candy bars. They provide a beautiful contrast on a holiday cookie platter alongside the Peppermint Bark Butterfinger Candy Bars.

Holiday Cranberry Meatballs

Looking for something savory to balance your sweet treats? These festive meatballs glazed with a tangy cranberry sauce deliver holiday colors and flavors in an appetizer form. Serve these at your holiday gathering before bringing out the Peppermint Bark Butterfinger Candy Bars for dessert for a complete entertainment menu.

These complementary recipes all share the holiday spirit and festive presentation of our Peppermint Bark Butterfinger Candy Bars while offering different flavor profiles and textures. Together, they create a well-rounded collection of special treats perfect for the holiday season.

Conclusion: Why Peppermint Bark Butterfinger Candy Bars Deserve a Place in Your Holiday Tradition

As we’ve explored every aspect of these Peppermint Bark Butterfinger Candy Bars – from the careful selection of ingredients to creative presentation ideas – it’s clear that this recipe offers something truly special for the holiday season. The magical combination of cool peppermint, smooth white chocolate, and crunchy, peanut buttery Butterfingers creates a memorable treat that stands out among traditional holiday offerings.

What makes these candy bars particularly worthy of becoming a new tradition is their perfect balance of familiar and unexpected. The peppermint bark base evokes classic holiday flavors that transport us back to cherished memories, while the addition of Butterfingers brings a surprising twist that keeps the experience fresh and exciting. It’s this blend of nostalgia and innovation that creates truly remarkable holiday traditions.

Beyond their delicious taste, these candy bars offer the gift of togetherness. The simple preparation process makes them ideal for creating with family members of all ages. Children can help with arranging Butterfingers or sprinkling candy cane pieces, while adults handle the chocolate melting. These shared moments in the kitchen often become as treasured as the treats themselves.

Whether you’re serving these at your holiday gathering, packaging them as heartfelt gifts, or simply enjoying them with your immediate family alongside a cup of hot cocoa, these Peppermint Bark Butterfinger Candy Bars bring joy through both their creation and consumption. They embody the spirit of holiday indulgence – special, a bit extravagant, and meant to be savored.

As you incorporate this recipe into your holiday repertoire, don’t be afraid to make it your own. The variations we’ve discussed are just starting points for your creativity. Perhaps your version with a special twist will become the most requested treat in your family for years to come.

This holiday season, take a moment to slow down and enjoy the process of creating something delicious to share with those you love. In our busy world, these moments of connection through food and tradition are more valuable than ever. These Peppermint Bark Butterfinger Candy Bars aren’t just a recipe – they’re an opportunity to create lasting memories wrapped in the sweet joy of the season.

Print